The Butterfly

a case study in performative spectacle

Overview

Authors

Photo of Venelin Kokalov

Venelin Kokalov

Design Principal

Revery Architecture Inc.

vkokalov@reveryarchitecture.com

Photo of Shinobu Homma, Architect AIBC, AAA, MRAIC

Shinobu Homma, Architect AIBC, AAA, MRAIC

Technical Principal

Revery Architecture Inc.

shomma@reveryarchitecture.com

Photo of Amirali Javidan

Amirali Javidan

Associate Director

Revery Architecture Inc.

ajavidan@reveryarchitecture.com

Photo of Zhuoli Yang, AIA, NCARB, LEED AP BD+C

Zhuoli Yang, AIA, NCARB, LEED AP BD+C

Architect

Revery Architecture Inc.

zyang@reveryarchitecture.com


Keywords


Abstract

Providing a unique and integral cladding/envelope solution suited for high-rise buildings has been an inherent challenge for this building typology since its conception. The progressively stringent energy codes and development policies (i.e. Vancouver’s new Energy Step Code, the Higher Buildings Policy, Large Sustainable Sites, and the Green Building Policy) demand an evolution of facade technology and practices. Coupled with advanced performance requirements, Architects are also challenged to incorporate culturally relevant design solutions to meet heightened aesthetic demands. This case study examines the facade system developed for the Butterfly tower in Vancouver, BC, detailing the innovations of the system, the process of development, and challenges faced.

The skin of the main tower consists of double-wythe, insulated, precast concrete panels and unitized, insulated ribbon windows structurally supported by the panels. The precast panels are geometrically complex: curved in plan to suit the tower’s cylindrical massing, undulated in elevation to offer unbounded views and bulged outward to form a dynamic urban expression while providing exceptional envelope performance. The envelope’s complimentary ribbon windows are similarly complex, curved in both plan and elevation.

In contrast to conventional exterior wall assemblies with discrete interior and exterior components, this uniquely integrated system condenses the entire assembly—interior finish, insulation, waterproofing, exterior finish and supporting structure—into a single entity, establishing material continuity between the exterior and interior.

In doing so, this innovative approach aims to simplify construction and sequencing to effectively minimize the time and cost required to deliver a finished exterior wall assembly. However, because all of the components are assembled before arriving on site, the need for precision in building construction is heightened, frontloading the design, testing, and manufacturing processes. To achieve the great geometric complexity without compromising performance and benefits of the sandwich panels were especially challenging in this respect.

Hence, this progress report focuses on the study of mock-ups for this unique envelope system. It’s believed that this experience would provide a reference for future developments in both facade design and the construction industry at large.

Introduction

Providing a unique and integral cladding/envelope solution suited for high-rise buildings has been an inherent challenge for this building typology since its conception. The progressively stringent energy codes and development

Members Only

Background

Since their conception nearly half a century ago, the production of precast concrete panels has favored methods that prioritize the efficient manufacture of a high volume of units at a

Members Only

Case Study

This case study focuses on the design development of the precast concrete sandwich panel and glazing system delving into the system itself and lessons learned in respect to the design

Members Only

Conclusion and Future Work

This study only shows some of the many challenges and solutions for the design of complex precast concrete sandwich panels for the Butterfly project. It focuses on showing the challenges

Members Only

Acknowledgements

Nicole Sylvia, Daniel Gasser, Envelope consultant-RDH, Precast concrete fabricator-APS, Construction and manufacturing technology company-CADmakers, Mechanical consultant-Integral Group, Structural consultant-Glotman Simpson.

Rights and Permissions

Revery Architecture, Spectral Consultants INC. "Innovative Design:Burrard and Nelson Post-Completion Design R&D Review." Section 1 – Section 2"

RDH. "9975_000 2017 12 06 DH LTR Th Env R8"

RDH. "9975_000 2018 03 07 DH – SVR1"

RDH. "9975_000 2018 03 07 DH – SVR2"

RDH. "9975_000 2018 03 07 DH - SVR3"

RDH. "9975_000 2018 03 07 DH – SVR4"

Integral Group. " FBC Preliminary Sustainability Energy Modeling Report 20171212"

CADmakers. " 2018044-SLAB DEFLECTION STUDY-3"

CADmakers. “2018-04-06_FBC Panel 3D Scanning Study”