Adaptive Facades

Towards Responsive Building Structures and Envelopes

Overview

Authors

Photo of Walter Haase

Walter Haase

ILEK, University of Stuttgart

walter.haase@ilek.uni-stuttgart.de

Photo of Werner Sobek

Werner Sobek

ILEK, University of Stuttgart

werner.sobek@ilek.uni-stuttgart.de

Photo of Enrica Oliva

Enrica Oliva

Werner Sobek New York

enrica.oliva@wernersobek.com

Photo of Michele Andaloro

Michele Andaloro

Project Manager and Engineer

Werner Sobek Stuttgart

michele.andaloro@wernersobek.com


Keywords


Abstract

Facade engineering aims at appropriately balancing the demands imposed by the context and the capabilities inherent to the materials, the geometries and the systems that are implemented. Traditionally, systems are designed for the worst case conditions, thus leading to static designs that are over-dimensioned for most of their service life. Therefore, if a system - just like a living body - is able to adapt itself to the external conditions by changing its properties, then it would bring about a new design paradigm that can lead to substantial savings and that can enhance the performance of the building.

Numerous researches, prototypes, and components have been carried out so far, and projects, both speculative and realized, are imagining the application of such systems on an architectural scale, in order to exploit their viable potential and redefine the premises on which the development of the built environment is set.

In this light, examples like the visionary proposal for house R129 (Sobek, 2001), where the transparent shell complemented with an electrochromatic foil enables the building to dynamically respond to the changing conditions of its context, or the Cité du Design in St. Etienne (Geipel and Andi, 2004), where the skin adapts to the interior requirements, have shaped this novel approach to envelope design and fueled the dialogue around the concept of adaptivity.

In this process, research institutions play a crucial role; indeed, through the promotion of studies and researches, innovative systems and methodologies are developed, thus fostering a continuous progress in the building sector, from a design as well as a manufacturing standpoint.

Among the researches currently carried out, this paper aims at presenting in particular two prototypes, developed at the Institute for Lightweight Structures and Conceptual Design (ILEK) in Stuttgart, which address the concept of adaptability with regards to two crucial performances and that introduce two influential references for the design and engineering of future transparent skins.

The first prototype, Research Project A, involves an adaptive glazed facade with vertically prestressed cables, where, by means of actuators, the active components, weaving together the double cables and changing their reciprocal distance, modulate the prestress forces and the curvature of the cables, according to the present loading condition measured by sensors, and optimize the structural behavior of the facade. The results show that - compared to a standard cable construction - the adaptive cables system can lead to a striking minimization of the members sizes and, as a consequence, of the material usage.

Research project A has been carried out by Christine Flaig (ILEK - University of Stuttgart), Dr. Walter Haase (ILEK - University of Stuttgart) and Michael Heidingsfeld (ISYS - University of Stuttgart) within the framework of the Research Group 981 (HIKE) funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG).

The second project, Research Project B, consists of a switchable glazing unit with adjustable light and energy transmission properties. While current switchable glass technologies feature long respond times and rough subdivision of the glazing area, the prototype developed enables substructured control and grey scale states, thus allowing a precise modulation of the daylighting and energy performances, without compromising the visual comfort. Ultimately, by linking together the data from the sun and the test room, an initial automated and dynamic control strategy has been implemented.

Research project B has been realized by Marzena Husser (ILEK - University of Stuttgart) and Dr. Walter Haase (ILEK - University of Stuttgart), supported by the Federal Institute for Research on Building, Urban Affairs and Spatial Development within the Federal Office for Building and Regional Planning, Germany (research projects: “Adaptive glazing systems”, “TN technology for architectural applications”) and by Baden-Württemberg Stiftung GmbH, Germany (research project: “i³: intelligent, interactive, integrative solar control glazing”).

Research Project A

Figure 1: Demand/capacity diagrams. Figure courtesy of the authors.Figure 2: R129 (left), Cité du Design, St. Etienne (right). Figure courtesy of Sobek W. and Kunze J.O.

Suspended facades with prestressed cables

Members Only

Background

In the framework of previous research on adaptive shell structures, innovative active supporting systems have been implemented in order to reduce and homogenize stresses and, therefore, minimize the structure’s deformation

Members Only

Method

Adaptivity Concept

The objectives of the developed adaptivity concept are to reduce the prestressing forces in the cables and to minimize the horizontal deflections.

In order to address these issues, two strategies

Members Only

Data

Compared to a traditional glass facade with vertically prestressed cables (INACTIVE) featuring the same configuration and subject to the same loading conditions (wind loads), the numerical simulations showed that the

Members Only

Conclusion and Future Work

The results show that the proposed adaptive glass facade with vertically prestressed cables has led to a significant reduction of the prestressing forces in the cables and, therefore, of the

Members Only

Research Project B

The dynamic nature of light and energy urges for innovative facade designs able to master the indoor environmental quality of a space, together with the thermal performance of the entire

Members Only

Background

The innovative switchable glass introduced consists of a thin substructured switchable cell, manufactured by BMG MIS GmbH Luminator Technology Group, inserted in an insulating glazing unit, provided by Okalux GmbH

Members Only

Method

The objectives of the following analyses are to study the potentials of the developed substructured switchable glazing, from an energy and daylighting standpoint, and constitute the basis for further implementations

Members Only

Data

The following diagrams, showing the analysis results in terms of energy demand, demonstrate that the TN-glazing is comparable to a triple insulating glazing with an external shading system (the present

Members Only

Conclusion and Future Work

The results show the potential of the developed substructured adaptive switchable glazing system in enabling to design for project-specific control strategies that dynamically optimize the energy performance of the facade

Members Only

Future Scenarios

Over the last decade, advances in engineering, design, and manufacturing have unveiled a high potential perspective for the construction field; indeed, if on the one hand, innovative design practices, in

Members Only

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to express their gratitude to the researchers at the Institute for Lightweight Structures and Conceptual Design (ILEK) that developed the presented prototypes as well as the institutions and the industrial partners that supported the projects.

Research project A - Christine Flaig (ILEK - University of Stuttgart), Dr. Walter Haase (ILEK - University of Stuttgart), and Michael Heidingsfeld (ISYS - University of Stuttgart).

Research project B - Marzena Husser (ILEK - University of Stuttgart) and Dr. Walter Haase (ILEK - University of Stuttgart).

Rights and Permissions

Flaig, C., Haase, W., Heidingsfeld, M., Sobek, W. “Prototype of an adaptive glass facade with vertically prestressed cables.” Engineered Transparency 2016: Glass in architecture and structural engineering (2016): 213-222.

Sobek, W., Rehle, N. “Beispiele fuer verglaste Vertikalseilfassaden. Herrn Prof.Dr.-Ing. Udo Peil zur Vollendung des 60. Lebensjahres gewidmet.” Stahlbau vol. 73 no. 4 (2004): 224-229.

Neuhaeuser, S., Weickgenannt, M., Haase, W., Sawodny, O. “Adaptive Tragwerke - Aktuelle Forschungen im Ultraleichtbau: Stahlbau” Stahlbau vol. 82 no. 6 (2013): 428-437.

Neuhaeuser, S., Weickgenannt, M., Witte, C., Haase, W., Sawodny, O., Sobek, W. “Stuttgart SmartShell – a full scale prototype of an adaptive shell structure.” Journal of the International Association for Shell and Spatial Structures vol. 54 no. 4 (2013): 259-270.

Flaig, C. “Untersuchung verglaster, adaptiver, vorgespannter Seilfassaden.” Institut für Leichtbau Entwerfen und Konstruieren, Universität Stuttgart, Stuttgart.

Haase, W., Husser, M., Sobek, W. “Adaptive Glazing Systems - Survey of Systems” AIM 2017 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Intelligent Mechatronics. Munich, 2017.

Husser, M., Haase, W., Hoß, P., Sobek, W. “New Possibilities of Sun and Glare Protection with a Structured Switchable Glazing” Challenging Glass 5. Ghent, 2016.

Chen, R. H. Liquid crystal displays: fundamental physics and technology. Wiley-Blackwell, 2011.

Fehringer, A. Vergleichende Analyse unterschiedlicher Regelungsstrategien schaltbarer Verglasungen unter besonderer Berücksichtigng der Einflussparameter Strahlung und Temperatur. University of Stuttgart, 2016.

Haase, W. Adaptive Strahlungstransmission von Verglasungen mit Flüssigkristallen. University of Stuttgart, 2004.

Haase, W., Husser, M. Schaltbare Verglasung auf der Basis von lyotropen und nematischen Flüssigkristallen. University of Stuttgart, 2014

Haase, W., Husser, M., Sobek, W. “Potentiale strukturierter, schaltbarer Verglasungen.” in Weller, B., Tasche, S., Glasbau, Ernst & Sohn GmbH & Co. KG, 2016.

Haase, W., Husser, M., Sobek, W., Kurz, E., Rau, L., Frühauf, N. “Flüssigkristall-basierte Verglasung zur Regelung des Licht- und Energieeintrags in Gebäude.” in Weller, B., Tasche, S., Glasbau, Ernst & Sohn GmbH & Co. KG, 2016.

Haase, W., Prskalo, M., Królak, M., Sobek, W., Kurz, E., Rau, L., Frühauf, N. “Switchable Glazing for Architectural Applications based on Liquid Crystal Technology.” Glass Performance Days, Tampere, 2011.

Hoß, P. Simulation des Einflusses verschiedener klimatischer Randbedingungen auf die Regelungsstrategie schaltbarer Verglasungen und den Gebäudeenergiebedarf. University of Stuttgart, 2015.

Husser, M., Haase, W., Sobek, W., Kurz, E., Rau, L., Frühauf, N. (2014). “Structured sun protection glazing. Engineered transparency.” International Conference at Glasstec, Düsseldorf, 2014

Lichtmeß, M. Aktivierung von Blend- und Sonnenschutzsystemen. Universität Wuppertal, 2008.

Reinhart, C. “Daysim, advanced daylight simulation software.” http://daysim.ning.com/ (accessed November 24, 2015).

The Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System. “TRNSYS” http://sel.me.wisc.edu/trnsys/ (accessed November 24, 2015).

U.S. Department of Energy. “Weather Data” http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/b... weatherdata_about.cfm (accessed in 2013).

Wienold, J. “Dynamic daylight glare evaluation.” Building Simulation (2009): 944-951.

Wienold, J., Christofferen, J. “Evaluation methods and development of a new glare prediction model for daylight environments with the use of CCD cameras.” Energy and buildings Vol.38 no.7 (2006): 743-757.